logo.png

Red, Yellow, Green: Who Decides What?

Monday, October 19, 2026

The KidzMatter Blog/Productivity/Red, Yellow, Green: Who Decides What?

At KidzMatter this month, I opened my breakout with a hand-raise: “Hands up if you’ve ever been told to own your ministry, and then told you can’t change anything.”
​

I asked because I know that seat. I spent a decade at a centralized multisite church and now serve at a decentralized one, and the feeling follows you across the line.

Here’s the tension underneath it. Who decides what has to be the same at every campus, and what gets to be different? Nobody puts that in a job description. Everybody feels it.

It’s the Design, Not Your Failure

Most churches went multisite to solve a space problem at the original campus. The systems were built there first, for that context, and everything since has been an adaptation. Then your campus pastor writes your review while Central owns your curriculum, and suddenly you’re standing between two bosses.

That isn’t dysfunction. Andy Grove, in High Output Management, says every large organization with a common purpose ends up hybrid. Not a compromise. An inevitability.

This is a tension to manage, not a problem to solve. And stewarding these tensions well starts with deciding, out loud, what’s what.

Red, Yellow, Green

I built a version of this for our church, and it changed more conversations than any org chart ever did. Three categories:

• Red: Stop. Same at every campus. No campus discretion.
• Yellow: Proceed with caution. Everyone does it, but how you do it has flex.
• Green: Go. However you want.

Here’s where churches commonly land:

• Red: safety policies, ratios, background checks, check-in and check-out, mission, vision, brand.
• Yellow: classroom age breakdowns, volunteer training content, campus budgets, local events.
• Green: volunteer appreciation, recruitment methods, huddle rhythms, family care at milestones, toy selection.

Everyone agrees on safety in about four seconds. After that it’s curriculum, room names, snacks, and, I promise, carpet. Curriculum is the loudest fight. Some churches make it hard red. Others offer a pre-approved menu. Others let campuses choose.

There’s no right answer on that chart. There’s only a decided answer and an undecided one. Undecided is what’s creating unproductive or unnamed tension on staff teams.

It’s important to mention that this is intended to be a living document. It might explicitly state that a red today could become a yellow tomorrow, and that campus leaders should speak into any of it. That’s permission many of us already have and have never used.

Build Yours This Month

Brad House and Gregg Allison, in MultiChurch, map multisite on a continuum where the real variable is who holds the power to set vision, make decisions, and spend money. Churches slide along that line constantly. You don’t have to wait for yours to slide on its own.

1. Write your own five reds, five yellows, and five greens. Not the official version. Yours: what you believe should be aligned, flexed, and free.
2. Take it to your supervisor within 30 days. Frame it as either “here’s a tension I’m feeling” or “here’s a solution I’d like to propose.”

Need actual sentences? Start with one of these:

• “Do we have this written down anywhere?” If yes: “When was it last revisited, and what has moved?”
• “I drafted what I think should be the same everywhere, what should flex, and what should be free. Can we look at it together?”

Will it be uncomfortable? Maybe. But friction is not division. The absence of friction isn’t peace. It’s usually avoidance under the guise of being polite.

Not in a multisite church? Run the same chart on your volunteer team. What’s red for every small group leader? What’s green?

You didn’t design this system, and you’re not responsible for fixing it alone. But you’re not powerless either. Change in multisite rarely comes from the top down. It comes from a kids pastor who asked the right question in the right room.

Go write your five, five, and five. Then ask.

Anthony Hunt is the NextGen Pastor at Mercy Road Church in Carmel, IN, author of The AI-Powered Church and the upcoming The AI-Informed Family, and a national conference speaker and coach. He equips ministry leaders and families to embrace innovation, lead with clarity, and multiply impact for the next generation.

customer1 png

Hi, it's Ryan and Beth

Founders of KidzMatter

Welcome to the KidzMatter Blog. Here you will find a growing library of content from the KidMin community. Need help recruiting nursery workers? Looking for budget hacks? Want the inside scoop on everything KidzMatter? You're at the right spot.

1 png

Your Secret Weapon in Kidmin

Membership with KidzMatter PRO strengthens your skills and links you with a thriving community committed to empowering kidmin leaders like you.